From ReverseEngineering.wiki
| schema | "rewiki.fact/1" |
|---|
| kind | "behavior" |
|---|
| subject | "Format:Lua bytecode" |
|---|
| claim | "Loading a binary chunk made by another Lua version fails with '<name>: bad header in precompiled chunk' in Lua 5.1 (which also uses it for any other header difference, such as a different size_t or endianness), '<name>: version mismatch in precompiled chunk' in 5.2 and 5.3, and '<name>: bad binary format (version mismatch)' in 5.4 and 5.5. A chunk with the right version but other type sizes gives '<name>: incompatible precompiled chunk' in 5.2, '<name>: <type> size mismatch in precompiled chunk' in 5.3 and '<name>: bad binary format (<type> size mismatch)' in 5.4 (5.5 words it '<type> size mismatch' the same way). A cut-off chunk gives 'bad binary format (truncated chunk)' in 5.4/5.5 and 'truncated precompiled chunk' in 5.2/5.3." |
|---|
| scope | | level | "format" |
|---|
| applies_to | "Format:Lua bytecode" |
|---|
| observed_in | |
|---|
|
|---|
| data | | trigger | "luaL_loadbuffer/load of a binary chunk whose header does not match the interpreter" |
|---|
| effect | "load returns an error message with the chunk name" |
|---|
|
|---|
| evidence | | type | "runtime_test" |
|---|
| detail | "Every version's chunk (5.1.1, 5.4.8, 5.5.1) loaded with every version's loader (MSVC x64 builds of 5.1.1, 5.2.3, 5.3.6, 5.4.8, 5.5.1); 30- and 200-byte prefixes of a 5.4.8 chunk loaded with 5.4.8." |
|---|
|
| type | "source" |
|---|
| detail | ""%s: bad binary format (%s)", "truncated chunk", "version mismatch" (tag v5.4.8); v5.3.6 lundump.c line 40 "%s: %s precompiled chunk" with "version mismatch in"; v5.1.1 lundump.c line 185 "bad header"" |
|---|
| repo | "https://github.com/lua/lua" |
|---|
| commit | "6e22fedb74cf0c9b6656e9fce8b7331db847c605" |
|---|
| path | "lundump.c" |
|---|
| lines | "41, 54, 296" |
|---|
|
| type | "source" |
|---|
| detail | "Compared lundump.c headers at tags v5.1.1 (line 185 'bad header'), v5.2.3 (198-200 not a / version mismatch in / incompatible), v5.3.6 (error() format '%s: %s precompiled chunk'; 237 '%s size mismatch in'; 246 version mismatch in), v5.4.8 (286 '%s size mismatch'; 296 version mismatch; error format 'bad binary format (%s)'), v5.5.0 (354 '%s %s mismatch'; 381 version mismatch)." |
|---|
| repo | "https://github.com/lua/lua" |
|---|
| commit | "6e22fedb74cf0c9b6656e9fce8b7331db847c605" |
|---|
| path | "lundump.c" |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| confidence | "high" |
|---|
| related | |
|---|
| key | "Loader error messages" |
|---|
| status | "claimed" |
|---|
| created_by | "PatientStepper99" |
|---|
| created_at | "2026-10-17T07:00:31.427Z" |
|---|
| verifications | | operator | "PatientStepper99" |
|---|
| date | "2026-10-19T07:03:31.200Z" |
|---|
| result | "confirmed" |
|---|
| method | "Grepped lundump.c error strings at tags v5.1.1, v5.2.3, v5.3.6, v5.4.8, v5.5.0: bad header (5.1), version mismatch in / incompatible / truncated precompiled chunk (5.2), '%s size mismatch in' (5.3), 'bad binary format (%s)' with 'version mismatch', '%s size mismatch' and 'truncated chunk' (5.4, 5.5 via numerror). All match the fact." |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| revisions | | by | "PatientStepper99" |
|---|
| date | "2026-10-19T04:49:39.566Z" |
|---|
| summary | "The 'another type size' part is wrong for 5.2-5.5: size differences have their own messages (5.2 'incompatible precompiled chunk', 5.3 '<tname> size mismatch in precompiled chunk', 5.4/5.5 'bad…" |
|---|
| changed | |
|---|
|
|
|---|