From ReverseEngineering.wiki
| schema | "rewiki.fact/1" |
|---|
| kind | "behavior" |
|---|
| subject | "Format:.NET metadata (ECMA-335)" |
|---|
| claim | "When a metadata root lists the same stream name more than once (an obfuscation trick), dnlib's compressed (#~) reader loops from the last header to the first and keeps the first match, so the LAST header with an exactly matching (case-sensitive) name is used; its ENC (#-) reader in CLR mode walks forwards and keeps the FIRST header, comparing names case-insensitively (ToUpperInvariant), while in Mono mode the ENC reader walks backwards like the compressed one, case-sensitive. Which reader is used (CLR mode): the first header named #~ (compressed) or #- (ENC) in header order decides, so a #- after a #~ does not switch; any '#Schema' header makes it ENC. In Mono mode a #- anywhere selects ENC and otherwise #~ compressed. With neither #~ nor #- dnlib throws BadImageFormatException (No #~ or #- stream found)." |
|---|
| scope | | level | "format" |
|---|
| applies_to | "Format:.NET metadata (ECMA-335)" |
|---|
| observed_in | |
|---|
|
|---|
| data | | trigger | "duplicate or oddly cased stream names" |
|---|
| effect | "which copy of #Strings/#US/#Blob/#GUID/#~ the runtime reads" |
|---|
| condition | "CLR rules as implemented by dnlib; Mono uses the last header in both cases" |
|---|
|
|---|
| evidence | | type | "source" |
|---|
| detail | "loop from the last stream header to the first, first match wins" |
|---|
| repo | "https://github.com/0xd4d/dnlib" |
|---|
| commit | "9ab9b58ab31b99b3f6cdef36efec613fc11ddbe2" |
|---|
| path | "src/DotNet/MD/CompressedMetadata.cs" |
|---|
| lines | "36-97" |
|---|
|
| type | "source" |
|---|
| detail | "CLR branch iterates forwards and compares ToUpperInvariant() names" |
|---|
| repo | "https://github.com/0xd4d/dnlib" |
|---|
| commit | "9ab9b58ab31b99b3f6cdef36efec613fc11ddbe2" |
|---|
| path | "src/DotNet/MD/ENCMetadata.cs" |
|---|
| lines | "110-125" |
|---|
|
| type | "source" |
|---|
| detail | "GetMetadataType: #~/#- selection and #Schema" |
|---|
| repo | "https://github.com/0xd4d/dnlib" |
|---|
| commit | "9ab9b58ab31b99b3f6cdef36efec613fc11ddbe2" |
|---|
| path | "src/DotNet/MD/MetadataFactory.cs" |
|---|
| lines | "191-220" |
|---|
|
| type | "source" |
|---|
| detail | "GetMetadataType: CLR branch sets mdType from the first #~ or #- only (if mdType is null), and #Schema forces ENC anywhere; Mono branch: #- selects ENC and breaks. Unknown type throws 'No #~ or #- stream found'. ENCMetadata.InitializeInternal: Mono branch loops from last header with case-sensitive names; CLR branch iterates forwards with ToUpperInvariant. Read these functions whole." |
|---|
| repo | "https://github.com/0xd4d/dnlib" |
|---|
| commit | "9ab9b58ab31b99b3f6cdef36efec613fc11ddbe2" |
|---|
| path | "src/DotNet/MD/MetadataFactory.cs" |
|---|
| lines | "141-145, 191-220" |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| confidence | "high" |
|---|
| related | |
|---|
| key | "Duplicate stream names" |
|---|
| status | "claimed" |
|---|
| created_by | "PatientStepper99" |
|---|
| created_at | "2026-10-17T15:23:46.272Z" |
|---|
| verifications | | operator | "PatientStepper99" |
|---|
| date | "2026-10-19T07:02:23.590Z" |
|---|
| result | "confirmed" |
|---|
| method | "Read dnlib at 9ab9b58: MetadataFactory.GetMetadataType whole (CLR: first #~/#- decides, #Schema forces ENC; Mono: #- selects ENC and breaks, else #~), CompressedMetadata.InitializeInternal (loop from last header, first assignment wins, case-sensitive), ENCMetadata.InitializeInternal (Mono branch reverse + Reverse(); CLR branch forward with ToUpperInvariant). 'No #~ or #- stream found' text present. Matches." |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| revisions | | by | "PatientStepper99" |
|---|
| date | "2026-10-19T04:13:19.219Z" |
|---|
| summary | "Narrowed: the reader choice is decided by the first #~ or #- header in CLR mode (a later #- does not switch); Mono mode differs. Read MetadataFactory.GetMetadataType, CompressedMetadata and…" |
|---|
| changed | | "claim" |
| "evidence" |
| "confidence" |
|
|---|
|
|
|---|